Proposals to halt on-screen examinations risk confusing concerns about children's screen time with the benefits of digital assessment, while leaving England behind international developments. The e-Assessment Association (eAA) is calling for an evidence-led debate about how assessment can better prepare young people for a digital and AI-enabled world.
Recent proposals from the Conservative Party to halt the introduction of on-screen examinations, restrict screen use in schools and reduce coursework in response to concerns about artificial intelligence reported by the BBC raise important questions about the future of education.
Protecting children's wellbeing, reducing distractions and ensuring technology supports learning are essential priorities. However, treating all screen use as equally harmful overlooks fundamental differences between smartphones, social media, digital learning tools and carefully designed digital assessments.
The question should not be whether children use screens, but how technology is used, for what purpose and with what educational benefit.
Smartphones and digital assessment are not the same thing
There are legitimate concerns about excessive smartphone use, social media, distraction and the impact of technology on children's health and wellbeing. These deserve serious attention. However, there is a significant difference between a child spending hours scrolling through social media and a student using a secure digital platform to demonstrate their knowledge, solve problems or complete an assessment. On-screen examinations are structured, controlled environments designed to measure learning. They are not equivalent to unrestricted access to smartphones or entertainment.
Conflating these very different activities risks creating policies that address one problem while introducing another.
Digital technology should never be used simply because it is available. Its value must be demonstrated through educational outcomes, accessibility, reliability and the quality of assessment it enables. But equally, rejecting digital assessment because of wider concerns about screen time would be a disproportionate response that overlooks its considerable potential.
Are we preparing students for the world they will enter?
Today's students will enter workplaces in which digital technology is fundamental to almost every profession. Artificial intelligence is already transforming how people research, analyse information, solve problems, communicate and make decisions. This raises a fundamental question: if education is intended to prepare young people for their futures, why would we insist that they demonstrate their knowledge and skills primarily through methods that increasingly bear little resemblance to the world beyond school?
Handwriting remains a valuable skill, as do reading, critical thinking and the ability to work independently. Digital assessment does not require abandoning these foundations. But pen-and-paper examinations should not be treated as the only credible way of demonstrating knowledge simply because they are familiar. Students need opportunities to develop digital confidence, navigate information critically and use emerging technologies responsibly. Assessment should reflect these changing expectations rather than remain disconnected from them.
Digital assessment offers opportunities that paper cannot
The case for digital assessment goes far beyond replacing a handwritten examination with an identical test on a screen. Well-designed digital assessment can offer more flexible, accessible and authentic ways for learners to demonstrate what they know and can do.
For example:
These benefits are not automatic. Digital assessments must be designed and implemented carefully, with appropriate safeguards for fairness, security, accessibility and reliability. Nevertheless, restricting their development would risk denying learners and educators opportunities to benefit from assessment methods that can measure skills and understanding in ways traditional examinations cannot.
AI should prompt us to rethink assessment, not retreat from it
Perhaps the most important issue raised by the proposals is the suggestion that reducing coursework and limiting digital examinations will help address concerns about students using generative AI. AI undoubtedly presents challenges for assessment integrity. It is increasingly difficult to establish whether work completed outside controlled conditions represents a student's independent contribution. But the answer cannot simply be to return to assessment practices designed for a world before AI existed. Instead, we need to ask a more fundamental question: is our current assessment system still fit for purpose in a digital and AI-enabled world?
If AI can produce convincing responses to traditional assessment tasks, we need to consider whether those tasks are measuring the knowledge, understanding and skills that matter most. This does not mean abandoning the assessment of independent knowledge or critical thinking. Quite the opposite. Students must be able to understand, question and evaluate AI-generated information rather than accept it uncritically. It does mean considering how assessment can distinguish between what learners know independently, how they apply that knowledge, and how effectively they can use digital and AI tools where appropriate. There will be circumstances in which AI use should be prohibited and independent performance must be demonstrated. There will also be opportunities to assess how students use AI responsibly, evaluate its outputs and exercise their own judgement.
Both approaches will be important. Simply removing opportunities to use technology risks leaving students less prepared for the very challenges education should equip them to navigate.
Patrick Coates, CEO of the e-Assessment Association, comments: "We should be deeply concerned about the suggestion that the response to AI and digital technology is to take assessment backwards. There is a fundamental difference between protecting children from the harmful effects of excessive smartphone use and preventing them from developing the skills they will need in a digital world.
"AI is changing what people need to know and how they work. That should prompt us to question whether our assessment system is fit for purpose, not simply reinforce methods developed for a different era. We need assessment that protects standards while embracing the opportunities to measure knowledge and skills in more meaningful, inclusive and authentic ways."
An evidence-led approach, not a choice between paper and screens
The eAA recognises that digital assessment is not appropriate in every circumstance and that the transition from paper requires careful consideration of equity, accessibility, infrastructure and assessment validity.
Ofqual's own research, published in December 2025, highlights the importance of understanding differences in how students perform on paper and screen. It identifies particular challenges for some reading-intensive and complex tasks, while also recognising the opportunities offered by digital assessment.
These findings reinforce the need for careful design, evaluation and implementation, rather than a blanket rejection of digital examinations.
Ofqual's consultation on regulating on-screen assessment also proposed a controlled introduction of digital GCSEs, AS and A levels, with safeguards to protect standards, fairness and public confidence.
The eAA supports this evidence-led approach. The question should be which assessment methods provide the most valid, fair and meaningful evidence of learning, not whether paper or screens are inherently better.
Looking forwards, not backwards: can England afford to be left behind?
Digital assessment is not an untested concept. It is already being used across education systems internationally, as well as extensively in professional qualifications, certification and workplace assessment.
Examples include:
These examples demonstrate that digital assessment is already an established part of education in different countries, although the extent of its use and approaches to implementation vary.
The UK also has significant expertise in digital assessment, particularly across professional, vocational and workplace qualifications. Organisations delivering assessments in sectors such as finance, healthcare, technology and professional certification already use digital platforms to assess knowledge, competence and practical skills. The challenge for England is therefore not whether digital assessment is possible, but how to introduce it responsibly and ensure learners benefit from the opportunities it provides.
If we halt progress while other education systems continue to develop and refine digital assessment, we risk falling behind in both assessment innovation and the preparation of young people for an increasingly digital world. This is particularly important as AI changes the skills employers need and the ways people work. Education systems that explore how to assess critical thinking, problem-solving, digital literacy and the responsible use of AI will be better positioned to respond to these changes.
The pace of technological development makes it more important than ever that our education and assessment systems evolve. That requires investment, research, collaboration and robust safeguards. It also requires a willingness to challenge established approaches.
The eAA encourages policymakers, regulators, educators and assessment organisations to engage in a constructive debate about how assessment should evolve, drawing on international experience and the growing body of evidence about digital assessment. Protecting children from harmful screen use is an important objective. But it should not come at the expense of preparing them for a digital future. Rather than asking how we can preserve pen-and-paper examinations, we should be asking how we can create an assessment system that is fit for the world our students will inherit.
Read more:
About the e-Assessment Association
As the global community for digital assessment, the e-Assessment Association brings together exam boards, regulators, technology providers, educators and employers to define best practice, share evidence and build trust in digital assessment.
Through collaboration, evidence and thought leadership, the eAA is helping shape a future where assessment is more accurate, inclusive and trusted for learners, institutions and employers worldwide.
Individuals can join the eAA for free. Find out more here.
Join the global community advancing e-assessment through innovation, research, and collaboration.
Keep informed